Overview: Committee Letter of Evaluation
The Committee Letter is an institutional letter of evaluation that highlights you as a multidimensional applicant. It ties together your academic record and scholarly accomplishments, personal attributes, experiences working and volunteering in the community, and your demonstrated commitment to healthcare. The letter will tell your story of why you selected this professional path and serves to introduce you – holistically – to all members of Admissions Committees.
Many health professional schools recommend that students obtain an institutional letter of evaluation (e.g. Committee Letter) if the service is available at his/her institution; however, some centralized application services and professional programs do not accept traditional NYU Committee Letters. If you plan to apply to Pharmacy, Physician Assistant, Public Health, or Veterinary programs, Special Master's Programs (SMPs), or postbacc programs, we ask that you email email@example.com to confirm that the Committee process is compatible with your goal before proceeding with the Committee process. Even if you do not need to use the Committee process, or ask for our letter, we are still excited to meet with you as you consider your potential career, assess your application readiness, and apply to your chosen health profession.
Eligibility to Receive a Committee Letter of Evaluation at NYU
All students who meet all of the following criteria are eligible to receive the services offered by the Prehealth Committee of Evaluation for a particular application cycle:
- You must have completed more than half of your prehealth science courses at NYU within the past ten (10) years while enrolled as a degree-seeking undergraduate or as a certficate recipient in our Postbaccalaureate Prehealth Studies Program
- You must be applying to an application service or school that is compatible with the committee process and
- You must have adhered to our office’s internal deadlines for that cycle.
Our committee will only evaluate your performance in courses completed at NYU. If you complete a SMP or postbacc program after completing your basic prehealth coursework at NYU, we strongly recommend requesting a committee letter from the institution where you most recently completed coursework, if you are eligible.
NYU students who DO NOT receive a Committee Letter for programs that expect one may lead admissions committee to assume that they are circumventing the process or that they did not follow our protocols. Avoid this negative insinuation by adhering to our prescribed deadlines.
Applying to Receive a Committee Letter of Evaluation
Students and alumni seeking a Committee Letter of Evaluation work closely with the staff of the Preprofessional Advising Center throughout the academic year preceding their summer application to health professional schools. The steps that NYU applicants complete to receive a Committee Letter is popularly referred to as the "Committee Process":
- Completion of a Prehealth Committee Application.
- Participation in a Committee Interview
- Solicitation of individual letters of evaluation
- Submission of a primary application to schools of the health professions with our letter properly documented
- Completion of your Committee Letter Request
- Discussion of each applicant by members of the Committee
A review of these materials and interactions allows us to write a personalized, thorough, and reliable Committee Letter to accompany your application to health professional schools.
The Prehealth Committee Application is an internal application completed by all NYU students and alumni seeking a Committee Letter. Your submission of an Application alerts our staff of your intention to use the services of the Committee and participate in our interview process. The Application provides Committee members with important information about you and your candidacy. Its structure and content has also been purposefully designed to look and feel like your professional school application.
The Prehealth Committee Application serves multiple purposes. Certain elements are designed to help the Committee accurately anticipate the number and variety of prehealth students who wish to participate in our Interview process and receive an institutional evaluation this summer. Understanding the volume of students we will be serving allows us to efficiently manage applicants’ needs in the months ahead. Additionally, parts of the application reveal your intentions and readiness to participate in the Committee process. We expect you to reflect and answer honestly when responding to these question. Members of our Committee may be in touch if we have questions or concerns related to your responses.
Finally, the essays, short answer questions, and professional preparation sections of the Application helps the Committee learn about you as a candidate. Your responses to these questions and prompts allows you to take stock of your experiences and attributes, practice good communication skills, and prepare the narrative you plan to present with your summer application to health professional schools.
The Committee Interview provides you the opportunity to discuss your portfolio with a member of the Prehealth Committee on Evaluations. This one-on-one, 30-60 minute interview may feel like a guided conversation where you’re able to share your personal/familial background, educational choices, professional goals, and the experiences that have informed your understanding of the health profession that you seek to enter. The Committee member will also be observing your communication style, interpersonal skills, maturity, and professionalism during this encounter. S/he may ask you pointed questions related to your preprofessional preparation and how you demonstrate the competencies that professional schools value. Examples of professional school competencies can be found online:
The Wasserman Center for Career Development offers in-person and web-based resources that can help you hone your interviewing skills so that you can put your best foot forward. We encourage you to use these services early and often.
It is important to keep in mind that the interview is not an advising session. It is a professional interview that will influence the Committee Letter of Evaluation. Please plan to arrive 10 minutes early to your interview site, dressed professionally, and prepared to engage in a meaningful conversation. Missing or arriving late to your scheduled interview will result in the forfeiture of your interview. Candidates only interview with the committee once. If you decide not to apply that cycle, you will not be granted an interview in later years. We strongly recommend students only interview in the year they are ready to apply to schools of the health professions.
Applicants who adhere to the Committee’s application deadline will be invited to schedule a one-hour interview. All interviews will be scheduled during a short window in February. Interviews will be conducted from February through May. For applicants no longer in the New York City area, or who will study away in the spring and will not return to New York until after May, we will work with you to arrange a telephone or virtual interview.
Incorporating your Letters of Evaluation
Individual letters of evaluation are important and essential components of your final Committee Letter of Evaluation. NYU’s Committee authors a composite-style letter; our Committee will reference and quote the content of these evaluations as a way of corroborating and underscoring elements of your candidacy. All evaluations in your prehealth file are submitted, unabridged, with your NYU Committee Letter of Evaluation. For this reason, you should not separately list individual evaluation writers who submitted letter(s) to the Preprofessional Advising Center in your primary application to professional schools.
Your Committee Letter of Evaluation can only be finalized once all anticipated letters of evaluation have been received. Waiting for the submission of a missing letter may delay the submission of your Committee Letter. It may be more effective to have the individual writer send it directly to AMCAS (for example) through its letters service, or directly to health professional schools, whenever s/he finishes it.
Read more about Letters of Evaluation
Information for Previously-Interviewed Applicants
If you have already participated in a Committee Interview with our office but chose to delay your application to professional programs, please know that you do not need to complete a new Prehealth Committee Application or have a second committee interview. In lieu of submitting a new application, we ask that you provide updates to the Committee at the time you request your new Committee Letter. You will be asked to provide the following updates:
- Updated resume
- Updated grades in BCPM courses
- Updated unofficial transcript
- Applicant Update Essay, in response to the following prompt: For students who interviewed with us in 2018 or prior but have never applied to schools of the health professions, what guided your decision to take a glide year after your interview? In what ways did you seek to strengthen your prehealth portfolio during that time? What were your goals for your glide year? In what ways have you accomplished these goals and in what ways are you still working on these goals? What about your Glide Year experience will make you a better clinician? Are there areas of your application you are still concerned about? Why is now the time to apply? [8000 characters max]
Applicants who require access to a past committee application to prepare their updates should contact firstname.lastname@example.org with their name, N number, and year in which they completed a committee interview. You will submit your updates as part of the process of requesting a new letter on or after June 1. Details about the process of electronically requesting your letter will be made available in May 2019.
NOTE: Re-applicants are asked to adhere to the instructions on the re-applicants page.
Documenting your Committee Letter within Centralized Application Services
Centralized application services expect applicants to properly identify the source of their institutional letter of evaluation. Please follow the directions below to ensure the accuracy of this letter entry:
- Select "Committee Letter" as your Letter Type
- Select "Electronic Evaluation" for any centralized application that requests this information
- Primary Author: Ms Danielle Brooks Delavaux, Assistant Dean for Preprofessional Advising
- Email address: email@example.com
New York University
Preprofessional Advising Center
100 Washington Square East, Silver 901
New York, NY 10003-6688
- Phone number: (212) 998-8160
- Due Date (for AACOMAS): 10/31/2019 - this is not the due date when we will actually send the letter, but it is the last time we would be transmitting a letter this year. Note that the due date you put down in your application has no effect on the committee timeline.
DO NOT include the names of the writers who submitted individual letters of evaluation to the Preprofessional Advising Center in your application. All evaluations in your prehealth file are submitted, unabridged, with your NYU Committee Letter of Evaluation. Noting the names of each evaluation writer separately in your application will give admissions personnel the false impression that these letters will arrive separately.
Submitting Your Committee Letter to Health Professional Programs
All students who adhere to the Preprofessional Advising Center’s published deadlines may request to have their Committee Letter and individual evaluations sent to the centralized application services and/or health professional programs to which they apply. We cannot move forward with discussing and preparing your Committee Letter, and we cannot send these documents to programs and centralized application services, until all of your individual letters of evaluation have been received. The Preprofessional Advising Center will only send materials that match the current offering of the Committee and have been updated for the current cycle; we do not simply re-upload packets or letters generated in previous years. Expect a 4-6 week turnaround each application cycle.
- The Committee on Evaluations will not finalize or submit Committee Letters before your centralized application has been submitted. In most cases, centralized applications cannot be submitted prior to June 1. Even in instances where you can submit your centralized application prior to June 1, we will not accept requests for Committee Letter before June 1.
- Please allow four (4) to six (6) weeks for the Committee Letter to be uploaded to the relevant online centralized application service (e.g., AMCAS, AACOMAS, or AADSAS) or the programs to which you applied. The four week processing period does not include university closures and holidays. Our timeline will in no way negatively impact your application. It takes four to six weeks for your application to be verified by the online application services.
- Our staff will send your Committee Letter and associated evaluations electronically, whenever possible, to expedite the transmission of these documents.
- You (the applicant) are responsible for meeting the deadlines of professional schools and ensuring that your file is complete at each of them. Schools do not consider your application complete until you have submitted secondary applications.
Submitting Your Committee Letter
For Fall 2019 Matriculants
Applicants planning to matriculate in a health professional program in Fall 2019 were expected to submit their request for a Committee Letter between June 1 - October 1, 2018. If you requested your Committee Letter during this timeframe and would like to have your Committee Letter sent to additional application services or schools for matriculation in Fall of 2019, you can use our Request Form to alert our staff and provide the details of where you would like your documents sent. Letters are only valid for the matriculation year that they were initially generated for; if you initially requested a letter in the summer of 2018 but are now applying for a program that begins in Fall of 2020, you will need to request an updated letter starting June 1 by following the Fall 2020 matriculants protocol below.
If you want to matriculate in Fall 2019 but did not request your Committee Letter between June 1 - October 1, 2018, please review the section below for instructions on requesting a letter packet.
For Summer 2019 Applicants - Fall 2020 Matriculants
We will reopen the request process on June 1, 2019 for applicants applying to begin health professional schools in Fall 2020. The request form is housed in the CAS Committee Letter Portal. You can log in with your NYU Net ID and password, even if you did not fill out a Committee Application this year.
You should use this Committee Letter Request Instructions guide with screenshots as you work through the application. The guide provides tips for many different situations for each step of the process.
The form will begin accepting responses on June 1. You may not see the form before June 1. That is not unexpected.
We will stop accepting requests for the year on October 1, 2019; we retain such a late request date for the benefit of our optometry candidates and strongly encourage all MD candidates to apply by early August.
To request the transmission of your letter, you will need to provide ALL of the following:
- a copy of your completed primary application
- an updated transcript
- an updated resume
- written updates
- agreement that the letters of evaluation displayed in the portal is the full list of letters we will include for you this year
For applicants who interviewed in Spring 2019, you can supply a short update on any changes since your initial application or interview or confirm in writing that there are no changes. Applicants who interviewed prior to Spring 2019 can preview the prompts they will need to address.
For each application service you would like us to send a letter to, you will need to provide any unique identifiers assigned to you by the application service. For AMCAS, this will be your AMCAS ID, Letter ID, and the Letter Request form. For AACOMAS, AADSAS, TMDSAS, and OptomCAS, we will need the Application ID number. For applications that require us to transmit the letters outside of a dedicated portal, we will need more detailed information on where to send the packet.
If you want to matriculate in Fall 2020 but were not eligible for a Committee Letter, please review the section below for instructions on requesting a letter packet.
Using NYU's Dossier Service/ Requesting a Letter Packet
NYU applicants who are ineligible for a Committee Letter of Evaluation may be authorized to use the Preprofessional Advising Center's dossier service. This service - the packaging of individual evaluations under the cover of the Preprofessional Advising Center - facilitates the submission of a "letter packet"without an adjoining evaluative Committee Letter. Applicants must request and be granted express permission by the Chair of the Committee on Evaluations to use the dossier service. To request permission, write to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Please contact email@example.com with any questions related to the submission of your Committee Letter of Evaluation or letter packet.
*Once your Committee Letter and associated evaluations or letter packet have been submitted to centralized application service(s), our staff will not transmit any additional evaluations sent on your behalf to the Preprofessional Advising Center. It is your responsibility to re-direct all evaluation writers to the appropriate evaluation transmission service (AMCAS, AACOMAS, AADSAS, etc.) associated with your application to facilitate the transmission of their evaluation directly.